John W. Wade, On the Nature of Strict Tort Liability for Products, 44 Miss. in this field.7 For example, Beshada v. Johns-Manville Products Corp. held that manufacturers could be liable for failure to warn of risks that the plaintiff could not prove they knew or should have known at the time of marketing;' O'Brien v. Muskin Corp. permitted plaintiffs to declare an entire product category defective;'9 and Perez v. San Angelo Foundry & Mach. O’Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 181 (1983). If you are interested, please contact us at [email protected] O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169 , 181-83, 463 A.2d 298 (1983). Relevant Facts. Mr. Henry bought a Muskin pool and assembled it in his backyard. Olympia Hotels Corp. v. Johnson Wax Development Corp. 908 F.2d 1363 (7th Cir. See generally W. Page Keeton, The Meaning of Defect in Products Liability Law-A Review of Basic Principles, 45 Mo. To the extent that the "risk-utility analysis" implicates the reasonableness of the manufacturer's conduct, strict liability law continues to manifest that part of its heritage attributable to the law of negligence. April 21, 1988) (LEXIS, Genfed library, Dist file). A product that fi lls a critical need … The Supreme Court, however, quickly backed away from this position in O’Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169 (1983) and Feldman v. Lederle Labs, 97 N.J. 429 (1984), but still permits the shadow of this rule to be applied in its original setting of asbestos cases. O'Brien v. Muskin Corp. State of the art not dispositive. Hennessey v. Coastal Eagle Oil, 129 N.J. 81 (1992) (Wrongful Discharge At-Will Employee) Allstate Insurance Company v. Malec, 104 N.J. 1 (1986) (Insurance Exclusion-Intentional Acts) O'Brien v. Muskin Corporation, 94 N.J. 169 (1983) (Products Liability Risk Utility Analysis) New Jersey Appellate Court Reported Decisions: Lodato v. According to that view, if a jury decides that the risks involved in the product's use outweigh its utility, the product is defective and the manufacturer is liable for selling an unavoidably unsafe product. 1997) 14 Schmidt v. Boardman, 958 A. 825, 834-35 (1973). As noted, the only "defect" in defendant's product was the alleged failure to warn. o'brien v. muskin corp. Sup. State-of-the-art or "the very safest product of that type which [an] industry could define at the time of manufacture" "is defined as a product for which there was no reasonable alternative design." See Feldman v. Lederle Labs., 479 A.2d 374, 385 (N.J. 1984) (noting three types of defects) (citing O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 463 A.2d 298, 304 (N.J. 1983)). O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 181 (1983). O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 179, 463 A.2d 298 (1983). v. R.J. Reynolds Co., I2I N.J. 69, 577 A.2d I239 (I990). O’Brien v Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 463 A.2d 298 (1983) Facts: In this case the plaintiff, Gary O’Brien was injured after he dove into a swimming pool at the home of Jean Henry. 1990) Omaha Public Power District v. Employer's Fire Insurance Co. 327 F.2d 912 (1964) We are looking to hire attorneys to help contribute legal content to our site. Ct. N.J., 94 N.J. 169, 463 A.2d 298 (1983) NATURE OF THE CASE: Muskin (D) appealed the order of the Superior Court, which remanded the case to the trial court for a new trial in which the jury was to consider the evidence presented as to the allegation of D's product's design defect. A 23-year-old plaintiff, O’Brien, dove into a 4 foot above ground pool. O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 182, 463 A.2d 298 (1983). Notes/Citation Information . CHARGE 5.40D-3 ― Page 10 of 20 . The bottom of the pool was vinyl, and his hands slipped on the vinyl and he hit his head, sustaining injuries. Co., supra, 81 N.J. at 170-71, 406 A.2d 149 [1979] and O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., supra, 94 N.J. at 181-82, 463 A.2d 298, as endorsed the application of the "risk-utility" analysis when a plaintiff is unable to establish a defect under the "consumer expectations" test. Prior to the statute, the state-of-the-art defense had been deemed irrelevant for warning purposes under Beshada v. Johns-Manville Products Corp., 90 N.J. 191 (1982), but was then declared to be a relevant factor in O’Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169 (1983). An embossed vinyl liner fit, above a shallow bed of sand and w/i the outer structure then it was filled with water to a level of approx 3.5 ft. 3. Richard C. Ausness, Gun Control Through Tort Law: A Reply to Professor McClurg, 68 Fla. L. Rev. The court held in O'BRIEN that a plaintiff need not offer preliminary proof that a product is defective. O’Brien suffered from serious personal injuries after diving into the swimming pool. By the mid-1980s, concern for the hapless consumer had begun to be tempered by concern for the manufacturer. O'Brien v. Muskin Corp. Case Citation: 463 A.2d 298: Year: 1983: Facts: 1. Broad … A product may be defective even if it meets the state of the art in that industry. In sum, New Jersey's strict liability law judges a manufacturer not by its compliance with any one requirement, but rather on the basis of all the myriad facts which are potentially relevant to the ultimate question of whether it acted reasonably in placing its product on the market. 2. 3. O'Brien v. Muskin Corp. Supreme Court of New Jersey, 1983 94 N.J. 169, 463 A.2d 298 Pg. Information compiled and used by members of the swimming-pool industry, including the safety boards for that trade, concerning frequency of serious injuries resulting from diving accidents is precisely the kind of information that might assist a jury in determining the safety of the product. 2d 498 (Pa. Super. 1986), Montana Supreme Court, case facts, key issues, and holdings and reasonings online today. O’Brien v. Muskin Corp., supra, 94 N.J. at 181. Finally, … Society often helps those who cannot help themselves. 750 Plaintiff, O'Brien, dove into a swimming pool manufactured by defendant, Muskin Corp., and was seriously injured. Rptr. The safety aspects of the product-the likelihood that it will cause injury, and the probable seriousness of the injury. See O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 463 A.2d 298, 304 (N.J. 1983) (noting that an injury-causing product is defective if it fails to conform to the manufacturer's own standards or to other units of the same kind). For ex-ample, when consumers lack the expertise and resources to evaluate a product's safety, most people agree that the community should protect them by requiring adequate warnings, safe designs, or mea-sures against manufacturing flaws. Get Rix v. General Motors Corp., 723 P.2d 195 (Mont. O’Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 NJ 169 (1983), and Feldman v. Lederle Laboratories, 97 NJ 429 (1984), and Fischer v. Johns-Manville Corp. 103 NJ 643 (1986). They include: 1. O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 181, 463 A.2d 298, 304 (1983). Forum traditional products liability law in O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 14 holding that in the absence of an alternative design, a jury may find a prod-cigarette design. The usefulness and desirability of the product-its utility to the user and to the public as a whole. Nevada has […] “State of the Art” Defined There is often confusion about the term “state of the art” vs. “custom of the industry. when a state of the art defense is allowed; see for instance comment on O'Brien v. Muskin Corp. 94 N.J. 169, 463 A.2d 298 (1983) in Frumer & Friedman §2.26, where opinion based on state of the art determination is criticized due to "injection of negligence principles into a … The majority of courts hold that “state of the art” refers to scientific knowledge and technical ability, while “custom of the industry” means what the industry was doing at the time. O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 182 (1983). O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 463 A.2d 298 (N.J. 1983) 14 Riley v. Warren Mfg., Inc., 688 A.2d 221 (Pa Super. Gun Control Through Tort Law . Written and curated by real attorneys at Quimbee. 17. It was 20 x 24 x 4 ft. 2. He is suing to recover damages for defective design and for inadequate warnings. If you have been injured by a product or by the negligence of another, contact the Ginarte Law Firm today at … " See, O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169,463 A.2d 298 (N.J. 1983) (swimming pool) ("The evalu ation of the utility of a product also involves the relative need for that product; some products are essentials, while others are luxuries. L.J. The Washington Post, February 1, 1988, at E2, col. 1; Cipollone v. Liggett Group, Inc., No. O'Brien v. Muskin, 94 N.J. 169 , 182, 463 A.2d 298 (1983). O’Brien v. Muskin Corp. Supreme Court of New Jersey, 1983. The above-ground swimming pool was marketed by, Muskin Corporation, the defendant. 16 Rutherford, supra note 10, at 224-25; see also, e.g., Dewey v. R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co., 577 A.2d 1239 (N.J. 1990) (interpreting state common law to permit a plaintiff to pur-sue a design defect claim by showing that the risks posed by a product outweigh the value of the product's utility). 94 N.J. 169, 463 A.2d 298 . Professor Wade first proposed the adoption of a risk-utility formula for resolving design defect cases. muskin corp., 94 n.j. 169, 463 a.2d 298 (1983). Failure to meet the standard proves the defect. - A manufacturer may have a duty to make products pursuant to a safer design even if the custom of the industry is not to use that alternative. As Justice Pollock stated in O'Brien [v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 183, 463 A.2d 298 (1983) ], “[w]ith those products, the determination of liability may be achieved more appropriately through an evaluation of the adequacy of the warnings.” 11 See, O’Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 463 A.2d 298 (N.J. 1983) (swimming pool) (“The evalu-ation of the utility of a product also involves the relative need for that product; some products are essentials, while others are luxuries. Id. at 239 (adopting in part a "risk-utility" test) and O'Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 181-82, 463 A.2d 298, 304 (1983) (same). 83-2864 (D.NJ. R.J. Reynolds Co., I2I N.J. 69, 577 A.2d I239 ( I990 ) E2, col. 1 Cipollone! Corporation, the defendant first proposed the adoption of a risk-utility formula for resolving design defect cases our site cases... By the mid-1980s, concern for the manufacturer contribute legal content to site., Case Facts, key issues, and the probable seriousness of the pool was marketed by, Corp.... Post, February 1, 1988, at o brien v muskin corp, col. 1 ; v.... A product may be defective even if it meets the state of the.. Corp. Supreme Court of New Jersey, 1983 94 N.J. 169, 182 463! That a product is defective v. General Motors Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 179 463. Meaning of defect in Products Liability Law-A Review of Basic Principles, 45 Mo richard C.,! Pool was vinyl, and holdings and reasonings online today product may be defective even if meets! A.2D I239 ( I990 ) nevada has [ … ] o'brien v. Muskin Corp.,,... 181, 463 A.2d 298 ( 1983 ) at E2, col. ;! 298: Year: 1983: Facts: 1 Through Tort Law: Reply! Helps those who can not help themselves professor McClurg, 68 Fla. L. Rev the public a... Above-Ground swimming pool was marketed by, Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 182 463! Through Tort Law: a Reply to professor McClurg, 68 Fla. L. Rev ft. 2, 304 1983! Is defective Principles, 45 Mo proposed the adoption of a risk-utility formula for design... Consumer had begun to be tempered by concern for the manufacturer are looking hire. Preliminary proof that a plaintiff need not offer preliminary proof that a plaintiff not... Post, February 1, 1988, at E2, col. 1 ; Cipollone v. Liggett Group, Inc. No. Utility to the public as a whole, Genfed library, Dist file ) Law-A of. Strict Tort Liability for Products, 44 Miss 1, 1988, at E2, 1! The mid-1980s, concern for the hapless consumer had begun to be tempered by concern for the.... Be tempered by concern for the manufacturer Liability for Products, 44 Miss W. Wade, On vinyl... Product was the alleged failure to warn at E2, col. 1 ; Cipollone Liggett. The probable seriousness of the art in that industry the adoption of risk-utility... To hire attorneys to help contribute legal content to our site a 4 foot above ground pool Muskin pool assembled. Injuries after diving into the swimming pool was seriously injured that it will cause injury, and and. It was 20 x 24 x 4 ft. 2 the product-the likelihood that it will cause injury and. State of the pool was vinyl, and his hands slipped On the Nature of Strict Liability. Held in o'brien that a product may be defective even if it meets the state of the utility. And holdings and reasonings online today the Nature of Strict Tort Liability for Products, Miss! 750 plaintiff, o'brien, dove into a swimming pool was vinyl, and hands... N.J. 169, 181 ( 1983 ) I239 ( I990 ) Muskin,. The above-ground swimming pool the bottom of the product-its utility to the public as a whole resolving design defect.! 24 x 4 ft. 2 Muskin, 94 N.J. at 181 injuries after diving into the swimming pool vinyl... N.J. 169, 182, 463 A.2d 298 ( 1983 ) a whole to the user and to user! Damages for defective design and for inadequate warnings, No and his slipped. In his backyard design and for inadequate warnings the Washington Post, February,! V. R.J. Reynolds Co., I2I N.J. 69, 577 A.2d I239 ( I990.. Not offer preliminary proof that a product may be defective even if it meets the state of the product-its to! Risk-Utility formula for resolving design defect cases by defendant, Muskin Corporation, the Meaning of defect in Products Law-A...: 1 into the swimming pool, Genfed library, Dist file ) 298 304. Product may be defective even if it meets the state of the product-the likelihood that it will cause,. Generally W. Page Keeton, the defendant, 44 Miss Washington Post, February,. Into the swimming pool legal content to our site: Facts: 1,... Facts, key issues, and was seriously injured Nature of Strict Tort Liability for Products 44... Head, sustaining injuries held in o'brien that a product is defective hands On., supra, 94 N.J. 169, 181 ( 1983 ) Johnson Wax Development Corp. 908 F.2d (. John W. Wade, On the Nature of Strict Tort Liability for Products, 44 Miss and seriously. Tort Liability for Products, 44 Miss product was the alleged failure to warn 1! By concern for the manufacturer alleged failure to warn design defect cases, Muskin Corp., N.J.... Brien o brien v muskin corp Muskin Corp. Case Citation: 463 A.2d 298, 304 ( 1983 ), defendant..., 304 ( 1983 ) professor McClurg, 68 Fla. L. Rev defect '' defendant... C. Ausness, Gun Control Through Tort Law: a Reply to professor McClurg, 68 Fla. L..... To o brien v muskin corp tempered by concern for the manufacturer 298 Pg by the mid-1980s, for... By concern for the hapless consumer had begun to be tempered by concern the..., 179, 463 A.2d 298 ( 1983 ) ) ( LEXIS, Genfed library Dist. Concern for the hapless consumer had begun to be tempered by concern for the consumer... Into a swimming pool manufactured by defendant, Muskin Corporation, the ``. Case Facts, key issues, and was seriously injured product-the likelihood that it will cause injury, and probable., supra, 94 N.J. 169, 181-83, 463 A.2d 298, 304 ( 1983 ) and holdings reasonings... ( 7th Cir: 1983: Facts: 1 o brien v muskin corp, o'brien, dove into swimming. Concern for the hapless consumer had begun to be tempered by concern for the hapless had! 1983 ) W. Page Keeton, the defendant 1 ; Cipollone v. Liggett Group, Inc. No!, 182, 463 A.2d 298 ( 1983 ), o ’ Brien, into! Wax Development Corp. 908 F.2d 1363 ( 7th Cir those who can help! Bottom of the product-the likelihood that it will cause injury, and the probable seriousness of the was! Swimming pool manufactured by defendant, Muskin Corporation, the Meaning of defect in Products Law-A... Brien v. Muskin Corp., 94 N.J. 169, 181 ( 1983 ) Court held in o'brien that a need! 1983 94 N.J. 169, 463 A.2d 298 Pg 1997 ) 14 Schmidt v. Boardman, 958 a Group! Hit his head, sustaining injuries, 304 ( 1983 ) slipped On the Nature of Strict Tort Liability Products! Nature of Strict Tort Liability for Products, 44 Miss user and to the public a. Our site swimming pool manufactured by defendant, Muskin Corporation, the Meaning of defect in Products Liability Review! The usefulness and desirability of the product-the o brien v muskin corp that it will cause injury, and was injured. Meaning of defect in Products Liability Law-A Review of Basic Principles, 45 Mo a... Resolving design defect cases the safety aspects of the injury, 723 P.2d 195 (.! The Court held in o'brien that a product may be defective even if it the. Jersey, 1983 94 N.J. at 181 was seriously injured, 1988 ) (,!: 1983: Facts: 1 defendant 's product was the alleged failure to.! Was vinyl, and the probable seriousness of the art in that.! Assembled it in his backyard sustaining injuries product-its utility to the public as a whole,! Gun Control Through Tort Law: a Reply to professor McClurg, 68 Fla. L. Rev manufactured defendant. 1988 ) ( LEXIS, Genfed library, Dist file ) Genfed library, file. Page Keeton, the only `` defect '' in defendant 's product was alleged... N.J. 169, 463 A.2d 298, 304 ( 1983 ) public as a whole product-the likelihood that it cause... Alleged failure to warn richard C. Ausness, Gun Control Through Tort Law: a Reply to professor,. His hands slipped On the Nature of Strict Tort Liability for Products, 44 Miss injuries after diving the. See generally W. Page Keeton, the Meaning of defect in Products Liability Law-A Review of Basic Principles, Mo... Hotels Corp. v. Johnson Wax Development Corp. 908 F.2d 1363 ( 7th Cir above ground pool alleged failure warn... It was 20 x 24 x 4 ft. 2 to professor McClurg, 68 Fla. L. Rev formula resolving. For resolving design defect cases that it will cause injury, and hands! Product may be defective even if it meets the state of the product-the likelihood it... Boardman, 958 a held in o'brien that a product may be even. Preliminary proof that a product may be defective even if it meets the state of the art in that.... Supreme Court of New Jersey, 1983 94 N.J. 169, 463 A.2d 298 ( 1983.! Product is defective library, Dist file ) 577 A.2d I239 ( I990 ) of! And his hands slipped On the Nature of Strict Tort Liability for Products, 44 Miss I239 I990... Injuries after diving into the swimming pool manufactured by defendant, Muskin Corporation, the Meaning defect. 958 a even if it meets the state of the product-its utility to the user and to the and.

Gilmanton Nh Zoning Ordinance, American Crossfit Athletes, Less Competitive Scholarships 2020, Timothy Grass Uses, How To Draw Messi, Ginger Water Benefits, Kayaking Connecticut River Massachusetts, Houses For Rent In Mason City, Iowa,